Pennsylvania has told every school in the state that lunch will be phone-free starting in the 2027-28 school year, and lunchrooms are about to fill with new clubs. Some of those clubs will last. Many will not, and the ones that order shirts in their first semester will leave a box of them in a supply closet. A new lunch club should meet for a full year before it orders club shirts. The shirt is the club's identity, and a club that started in September has not built one yet.
Pennsylvania's phone ban covers lunch, and schools will fill that time with clubs
Pennsylvania's new law makes lunch phone-free in every public and private school in the state. Gov. Josh Shapiro signed Senate Bill 1014 on October 26, 2026. The governor's office says the law requires public, charter, cyber charter and private schools to adopt policies that ban personal cell phone use throughout the school day, including lunch. Chalkbeat reported that the ban covers the entire school day, including lunch, recess, homeroom and passing periods. Schools have until the start of the 2027-28 school year, and the bill provides no additional funding to help them carry it out.
Neither the law nor the governor's announcement mentions clubs. The goal the announcement names is for students to engage with their peers and build social skills. Schools that have already gone phone-free show what usually comes next. Education Week reported that Spokane, Washington, created or expanded scores of clubs, sports teams and other extracurricular activities as part of its effort to curb phones. One middle school added lunchtime tournaments and board games and turned its morning advisory period over to clubs. Pennsylvania advisors, PTA parents and student leaders should expect the same wave: many clubs, started quickly, to give students something to do at a table with no phones on it.
School club t-shirts are the club's identity, and a new club has not built one
School club t-shirts work because the shirt is the club's identity, planned by the advisor with the student leaders. A good club shirt carries things the members already recognize: the name they actually call themselves, the symbol someone drew on the whiteboard at the third meeting, the founding year, and sometimes a line only members understand. A shirt for student council, the robotics team or the chess club is a record of who the group has become.
A club in its first semester has none of that yet. Its name came from a sign-up form. Its members are students who were curious in September, and its advisor may still be working out which day the room is free. A shirt designed at that stage is a guess about an identity that has not formed yet. The design tends to come out generic because there is nothing specific to put on it, and a generic shirt is the one members stop wearing first.
New school routines lose strength between October and May
Energy in a new school routine tends to peak in the fall and thin out by spring, and the clearest recent evidence comes from the phone bans themselves. Researchers from the University of Southern California, writing for Brookings, surveyed teens in October 2025 and again in May 2026. They found that the enforcement and effectiveness of school phone policies faded between those two months. The share of teens who said they had used a phone in core classes rose from 28% to 42%, and 44% said their teachers became less strict over the year. The researchers suggested that the early-year focus on routines gave way to a focus on covering content.
The Brookings study measured phone rules, not clubs, and no one has yet published data on how many lunch clubs survive a full year. The evidence on club survival is thin. The pattern still matters to a club advisor. A lunch club is a school routine that starts in the fall on fresh attention, and the Brookings data shows how fresh attention holds up by May. Spokane's experience adds a staffing warning: Education Week found that at some schools, the same few teachers volunteer to lead clubs. A club that depends on one worn-out volunteer in March may not make it to the next September.
Shirts ordered in the first semester end up in a box
A first-semester shirt order sets the club's size at its largest and least reliable moment. When an advisor collects sizes in October, the list includes every student who came to the first two meetings. Some of those students will move to another club, some will end up in a lunch period that no longer lines up, and some will just stop coming. The shirts arrive for all of them.
Families pay for those shirts, and a new club should take that cost seriously. Collecting sizes and payments together is the right way to run any club order, and it also shows the problem clearly. Asking a parent to pay for a club shirt in October means asking them to bet on a club their child joined three weeks earlier. When the ban takes effect in 2027-28, many Pennsylvania schools will start several lunch clubs at once. If every one of them orders shirts in its first semester, the supply closets of 2029 will hold stacks of shirts for clubs that no longer meet.
The strongest case for ordering early is that a shirt can hold a new club together
The best argument against waiting is that a shirt builds a club's identity instead of only recording it. A student who wears the club shirt on a Friday has told the whole school where they belong, and that public commitment can be what brings a shy freshman back the next week. A shirt also recruits, because other students see it in the hallway and ask about it. If a new club fades because nothing made its members feel like members, waiting a year for shirts could be part of the reason.
The objection is right about belonging and wrong about the tool. A new club does need a visible identity in its first year, and it can get one from things that cost families nothing and can change as the club changes: a name on the morning announcements, a sign on the classroom door, a table that is always the club's, a group photo in the yearbook. Those markers recruit and build commitment without locking in a design, a roster and a size list before the club knows what it is. A shirt asked to hold a club together is being asked to do the work the meetings should do.
The objection does sharpen the rule in one place. An established group that moves its meetings to lunch because of the ban, such as a robotics team or a choir section, already has a year or more of identity behind it. The one-year wait applies to new clubs, not to existing clubs in a new time slot.
A new lunch club spends its first year building what the shirt will carry
The first year of a lunch club is when the advisor and student leaders gather everything a good shirt needs. Track attendance at every meeting instead of relying on the September sign-up sheet, so the roster in May shows who actually comes. Write down the name members really use, the inside jokes that stick and the sketches members draw without being asked. Record the founding year, because it will appear on the shirt for as long as the club exists.
The first year is also the time to learn who approves what. If the club wants the school's name or mascot on a shirt, the school has to sign off on that use, and finding out who signs off is easier in a calm February than in a rushed week before a spring event. By the end of the year, the club knows three things it could not know in September: who its members are, what it calls itself and whether it will meet again next fall.
The first club shirt order belongs at the start of the club's second year
A lunch club that has met for a full school year is ready to plan its first shirt order, and the order works best at the start of year two. The advisor approves the design with the student leaders, the school signs off on its name and mascot, and every name and date is proofread before print. Sizes and payments come in together, so the number of shirts the club orders matches the number families have already paid for. Order a few extras, because new members will join in the fall and a small reorder costs more per shirt.
Some clubs will reach the end of the year and find that the honest answer is to skip shirts entirely. A club of five students who play chess every Tuesday may be better served by a club photo and a line in the yearbook. Impact SpiritWear's position on school club t-shirts is that saying so is part of the advice. A club too small or too new for an order should wait, and a shirt that waited a year means something to the students who wear it.
A shirt asked to hold a club together is being asked to do the work the meetings should do.
Pennsylvania's ban will give thousands of students a lunch period with nothing on the table but each other, and that is a good start for new clubs. The clubs that matter will still be meeting in the spring of 2028. Those are the clubs that should order shirts, with a design built over a year, a roster they can trust and a founding year that means something.
Further reading
- Chalkbeat, report on Gov. Josh Shapiro signing Pennsylvania's bell-to-bell school cellphone ban, covering lunch, the 2027-28 start and the lack of added funding chalkbeat.org/philadelphia/2026/10/26/pennsylvania-school-cellphone-ban-signed-by-josh-shapiro
- Office of the Governor of Pennsylvania, official announcement of the signing of SB 1014 and the schools it covers pa.gov/governor/newsroom/2026-press-releases
- Education Week, Alyson Klein on how Spokane Public Schools created and expanded clubs as part of its effort to curb phones, including staffing strain edweek.org/leadership/one-districts-battle-to-curb-cellphones
- Brookings, USC researchers' survey of teens in October 2025 and May 2026 showing school phone policy enforcement fading over the year brookings.edu/articles/a-year-later-what-teens-tell-us-about-school-cellphone-bans