Guide

Can a school club require members to buy the club shirt?

In a California public school, a shirt members must buy to belong, compete or perform counts as a pupil fee. Here is where the line sits, where well-meaning clubs cross it, and how to get every member a shirt anyway.

· 4 minute read

The usual club shirt plan goes like this: pick a design, every member pays, everyone wears it to the competition. In a California public school, that plan breaks the law the moment buying the shirt becomes a condition of being in the club. The fix is simple, and it changes who pays and how the order is placed.

What does California law say about required club shirts?

California Education Code section 49011 says a pupil enrolled in a public school "shall not be required to pay a pupil fee for participation in an educational activity." Section 49010 defines an educational activity to include curricular and extracurricular activities offered by a school, and it defines a pupil fee to include "a purchase that a pupil is required to make to obtain materials, supplies, equipment, or uniforms associated with an educational activity." A matching shirt that members must buy before they can compete, perform or count as members fits that definition. The rule reaches charter schools and alternative schools too.

The California Department of Education's fiscal advisory on pupil fees, FMA 23-02 (November 2023), lists "membership fees in a student body or any student organization as a condition for enrollment or participation" in school-sponsored extracurricular activities among the charges a school cannot impose. A required shirt does the same work as a membership fee with a design printed on it.

Does a fee waiver for families who cannot pay fix it?

No. Section 49011(b)(2) says it directly: "A fee waiver policy shall not make a pupil fee permissible." The CDE advisory makes the same point about caps and gowns, saying no student should have to self-identify as indigent to receive one from the district. Offering a free shirt to members who ask still leaves the shirt a required purchase for everyone else.

Can the shirt be optional but come with perks?

This is where careful clubs most often slip. Section 49011(b)(4) bars a school from offering privileges related to educational activities in exchange for money, and from taking privileges away from a student whose family does not pay. If only members in the shirt stand in the yearbook photo, travel to the regional meet or walk on stage at the showcase, the shirt is not optional. An optional shirt is one a member can skip with no change in what they get to do.

What can a club do instead?

  • Buy the shirts from the club account and hand them out. If the shirt is part of how the club appears at events, budget for it like any other supply. Section 49011(c) expressly allows voluntary fundraising and voluntary donations, so a fall fundraiser can pay for spring shirts.
  • Sell the shirt as an optional keepsake. Members, families and alumni buy as many as they like, and nobody is asked to. The club keeps the margin.
  • Ask for a donation, worded as a donation. Every member gets a shirt whether or not the family gives.
  • Split the order. A club-paid set for members who represent the club, and a separate optional sale for supporters.

The fundraiser itself follows the district's student body (ASB) rules. Many California districts base those rules on the FCMAT ASB Accounting Manual, and district procedures commonly require a fundraiser to be approved in advance, in club minutes and by an administrator, before any money changes hands.

What happens if a school gets it wrong?

Under Education Code section 49013, anyone can file a complaint about an unlawful pupil fee with the principal under the district's Uniform Complaint Procedures, and the decision can be appealed to the CDE. A complaint can be filed anonymously when it includes evidence or information leading to evidence. When a complaint has merit, the school must provide a remedy to all affected students and families, including reasonable efforts to ensure full reimbursement. Custom shirts cannot be returned once they are printed, so a club in that position refunds every member out of its own account and keeps the shirts it already paid for.

Does this apply outside California, or in private schools?

These statutes govern California public schools, including charters. Private schools fall outside them. Other states write their own student fee rules, and some allow activity fees that California does not. Before collecting a dollar from members, ask the district business office or ASB bookkeeper one question: may this shirt be required, or must it be optional? Then order to match the answer.

How does the answer change the order?

When the club pays, the size sheet still matters, but the count and the payment come from one account. Impact SpiritWear takes card payment by phone at 800-704-5578 and school checks with the one-page check payment agreement. For an optional sale, an online school store lets each buyer pick a size and pay online, at a selling price the club sets, with the profit paid to the program. Either way, a designer builds the mockup free when the shirts are printed with Impact SpiritWear, and nothing prints until the advisor approves it. Get your free mockup.

Have an idea for your shirts?

Tell us what you have in mind. A designer turns it into a design for you to approve, and you can call us anytime during business hours.

Get Free Mockup